So, Cathy and I were just chatting idly about blogging while wrapping up a few evening tasks in the office, and she expressed a rather negative opinion of my tone and style in this blog. After a few back-and-forths nailing down what exactly she objected to, she finally admitted this:
Cathy: “Your blog’s tone is black and cynical.”
Me: “What? WHAT!? Can I quote you on that? Cathy McDonald says ‘this blog is black and cynical.’”
Cathy: “That’s understated. Let’s be more accurate. Your blog is depressing and it makes me want to stick a pencil in my eye and swirl it around.”
Yes, those were her exact words: “stick a pencil in my eye and swirl it around.” I was flabbergasted… I mean, I know I tend to posture myself as a fatalist (more out of habit than actuality, I think) but I had no idea that my tone read that bad.
The real question that keeps coming to mind is… should I consider this a victory or a failure?


